Innerspring Mattresses

Innerspring vs foam vs hybrid

Box spring or foundation? Many beds sold as “sets” today want a flat, rigid foundation, not an old-style springy box spring. It looks the same and sits on the same frame. Sealy, Stearns & Foster and Beautyrest say a traditional box spring can void the warranty; Saatva says a box spring is fine. Check the “Base needed” column. Every bed here is researched from brand pages and trusted reviews, not tested by us.

Sharing a bed? Read Queen vs King for Couples: Is a Queen Big Enough for Two?

Swipe for more →

ProductScorePrice3-yr costBase needed
Stearns & Foster Estate
Strengths: features & build, durability
88Queen from $2,399 at stearnsandfoster.com
Buy at Stearns & Foster →
$2,399Foundation required (no box spring); from $315
Saatva Classic
Strengths: features & build, durability
85Queen from $1,895 at saatva.com
Buy at Saatva →
$1,895Box spring OK; foundation $345
Beautyrest Black Series Two
Strengths: features & build, upkeep
80Queen from $2,749 at beautyrest.com
Buy at Beautyrest →
$2,749Rigid foundation required; price unknown
Sealy Posturepedic Spring
Strengths: upkeep, evidence
80Queen from $699 at sealy.com
Buy at Sealy →
$699Foundation required (no box spring); queen $250
Serta Perfect Sleeper Cascade Range
Strengths: upkeep, ease of use
76Queen from $999 at serta.com
Buy at Serta →
$999Foundation recommended (sold as set); price unknown
Linenspa 8″ Memory Foam & Innerspring Hybrid (Budget Pick)
Strengths: upkeep, ease of use
70Check Amazon
Check price on Amazon →
unknownUnknown

Score guide: 90+ Outstanding · 80s Great · 70s Good · 60s Fair · below 60 Skip. How we score

Weekly email coming soon.